Reading a Tyre Quote in Melbourne: What an All-In Price Should Cover

You ring three tyre shops on a Saturday morning, ask each of them for a price on four new tyres for the same car, and write the answers on the back of an envelope. Three numbers come back, and they are not close. One sounds too good to be true, one sounds about right, and one makes you wonder whether you misheard.

If you have been there, please know you are not bad at this. Tyre quotes are genuinely hard to compare, because the same words can mean quite different things from one shop to the next. “Fitted” might include everything you need, or very little. “All-in” might mean all-in, or nearly. The good news is that once each line of a quote is named, two quotes become much easier to put side by side. This guide walks you through those lines, gently and in order, so the next time you are holding three numbers you will know what to ask.

The size code and the placard

Before you can compare prices, you need to be sure every shop is quoting on the right tyre. That starts with a little code you may never have looked at closely.

The RACV explains that you can find your car’s tyre size in two places: printed on the wall of the tyre itself, or on the tyre placard, a small sticker or plate usually found inside the driver’s door jamb. It is worth opening the door and finding it now, because the placard tells you what the car was designed to run on, which is not always what the previous owner put on it.

The code looks something like 205/55 R16 91V. It reads in parts:

  • 205 is the width of the tyre.
  • 55 is the profile, the height of the sidewall relative to the width.
  • R16 is the rim size the tyre fits.
  • 91 is the load index, which tells you how much weight the tyre is designed to carry.
  • V is the speed symbol, which tells you the speed the tyre is rated for.

The first three numbers are about fit. The last two are about safety, and they are the ones most easily lost in a phone conversation about price. Replacement tyres should meet the load and speed rating shown on your car’s placard. If you are not sure whether a tyre you have been quoted does, ask the shop to confirm it for you. A good shop will be happy to check.

The same idea of the placard as the benchmark turns up in Victoria’s vehicle standards too. The Department of Transport and Planning’s guide to modifying vehicles notes that alloy wheels need a load rating at least equal to the one on the vehicle’s tyre placard. That rule is about wheels rather than tyres, but it tells you how seriously the placard figures are taken.

When you ring for a quote, read out the full code from the placard, not just the size. It takes a few seconds and saves a lot of confusion later.

You may find that the code on the tyres currently on your car does not quite match the placard. That can happen for all sorts of reasons, especially on a car that has had more than one owner, and it is nothing to panic about. Simply tell the shop what you have found on both, and ask them to quote on tyres that meet the placard’s load and speed rating. Let them confirm it for you rather than guessing between the two.

Close view of the tread blocks and grooves of a new tyre, with a tread-wear bar marked in one groove

What “fitted” should include

This is where most of the gap between quotes tends to hide.

When a shop says a price is “fitted”, it can mean a few different things. Some shops include every part of the job in that one number. Others include the fitting itself and add the rest at the counter. Neither is wrong, but you deserve to know which one you are being offered before you book.

A complete fitted price usually covers these parts of the job. You might like to ask about each one by name:

  • Fitting. Taking the old tyre off the wheel and putting the new one on.
  • Balancing. Spinning each wheel on a machine and adding small weights so it turns evenly. Without it, you can feel a wobble through the steering wheel at speed.
  • New valves. The small valve each tyre is inflated through. Ask whether new ones are fitted with the new tyres.
  • Disposal of the old tyres. Old tyres have to be disposed of properly, and some shops charge for it separately.
  • Wheel nut torque check. Tightening the wheel nuts to the correct setting once the wheels are back on.
  • TPMS sensors. If your car has a tyre pressure monitoring system, its sensors sit inside the wheels. Ask whether the sensors will be serviced, and whether that is included or extra.

For each of these, you are looking for one of two answers: it is a named line on the quote, or the shop confirms it is included in the price. Either is fine. What you want to avoid is finding out at the counter that something you assumed was included was not.

It can feel a little awkward to go through a list like this on the phone. Most tyre shops field these questions all day, though, and a clear answer is a good sign about the shop.

Alignment is its own line

Wheel alignment comes up in almost every tyre conversation, and it is one of the most common sources of confusion, so it is worth giving it a little space.

Alignment is different from balancing. Balancing makes each wheel spin evenly. Alignment sets the angles at which the wheels sit relative to the car and to each other, so the car tracks straight and the tyres meet the road evenly. It is a separate service, done on a separate machine, and it should appear as its own line on a quote rather than being folded into the fitting.

The RACV notes that poor alignment can wear tyres prematurely, and that a steering wheel sitting off-centre when you are driving straight is one sign something is out. If you notice the car pulling to one side, that is worth mentioning too.

So do you need an alignment every time you buy new tyres? Not always. It is not automatically required, and if a shop recommends one, it is perfectly fine to ask why. It is often worth doing, though, if your old tyres wore unevenly, for example more on the inside or outside edge than across the middle. Uneven wear on the old tyres can be a sign the alignment is out, and fitting new tyres to a car that is out of alignment can mean they start wearing the same way.

If you do have an alignment done, ask for the before and after readings, on paper or by email. They show you what was out and what was adjusted, and they are a simple way to see that the work was actually done.

Price-beat and online prices

You might have seen tyre shops advertising that they will beat any price. That can be useful, but it helps to know what a price beat usually needs before you rely on one.

A price beat generally only works when the comparison is like for like. That means the same tyre, the same brand and model, the same size, and the same inclusions. A quote from another shop that leaves out balancing or disposal is not the same price, even if the headline number is lower, and the shop being asked to beat it may reasonably point that out. If you are planning to ask for a price beat, bring the other quote in writing, with each inclusion named.

Online tyre prices can be a good starting point too, and lots of people use them to get a feel for the market. Just keep in mind that an online price is often for the tyre alone, without fitting. Once you add fitting, balancing, valves and disposal at a local shop, the total can look quite different. The online price may be perfectly honest. You would just be comparing a tyre with a fitted tyre, and those are two different things.

If you do buy tyres online and have them sent to a local shop for fitting, ring the shop first. Ask what they charge to fit tyres supplied by a customer, and whether balancing, valves and disposal are included in that. Some shops are happy to do it, some prefer not to, and it is much nicer to find out before the boxes arrive on their doorstep.

Repairs versus replacement

Sometimes the question is not four new tyres but one flat one. You pick up a screw somewhere along the way, and you want to know whether it can be fixed.

Whether a puncture can be repaired is the shop’s call, made within its own rules and the guidance it follows. Where the puncture is, how big it is and the state of the tyre all come into it. A repair that is possible on one tyre may not be on another, and two shops can sometimes reach different answers.

If a shop tells you a tyre cannot be repaired and needs replacing, it is completely reasonable to ask why. You might like to ask for the reason in writing, or at least noted on the quote or invoice. A good shop will explain what it saw and where. That gives you a clear basis for your decision, and if you want a second opinion, it gives the next shop something specific to look at.

Comparing quotes

Now for the envelope. With everything above in mind, comparing tyre quotes becomes a gentle, step-by-step job rather than a guessing game.

Start with the tyre itself. Check that each quote is for:

  1. the same brand and model
  2. the same size
  3. the same load index and speed symbol, matching your placard

If any of these differ, the quotes are not for the same thing yet. Ask the shops to quote on the same tyre, or at least on tyres that meet your placard rating.

Then look at the inclusions. For each quote, check whether fitting, balancing, new valves, disposal, the torque check and any TPMS work are named lines or confirmed as included. Alignment should be its own line, if you want it at all. Once every quote covers the same things, you can finally compare the totals fairly.

It can help to picture how this plays out. Say the quote that sounded too good to be true turns out to be for a different tyre model, with balancing and disposal charged on top. The middle quote is for the right tyre, with everything included. The one that made you wince includes an alignment you had not asked for. Strip the alignment out, add the missing lines to the first, and the three numbers on your envelope may end up much closer together than they first looked. Sometimes the cheapest really is the cheapest. You just cannot tell until the lines match.

If writing it all out sounds like a lot, a simple grid on a piece of paper works well: the three shops across the top, and the tyre, the code and each inclusion down the side. Tick what each shop has confirmed, and the gaps show up straight away.

It helps to ask for the quote in writing, by email or text, rather than relying on a number read out over the phone. A written quote is easier to compare, and it is also what you will want if there is a problem later. This is the same habit this site recommends for other car work. The guide to choosing a smash repairer in Melbourne walks through getting a written quote and understanding the warranty on repairs, and the same questions about what is covered apply to tyres.

And if a tyre does fail on the road before you get to the shop, the first job is getting yourself and the car somewhere safe. This site’s guide to choosing a tow truck in Melbourne covers what to ask when you need one, so you are not making decisions in a hurry on the side of the road.

Name every line, then compare

Tyre shopping can feel overwhelming when three numbers on an envelope refuse to line up. You do not need to become a tyre expert to make sense of them, though. You just need each quote to name what it includes.

Start with the placard inside the driver’s door, and read the full code to each shop, including the load index and speed symbol. Ask whether the price covers fitting, balancing, new valves, disposal, a torque check and any TPMS work. Treat alignment as its own line, worth doing if your old tyres wore unevenly, and ask for the before and after readings. Remember that a price beat needs the same tyre and the same inclusions, and that online prices often leave out fitting. If a shop says a tyre cannot be repaired, it is fine to ask why. Then put the written quotes side by side, and you will be comparing like with like.

Sources: How to buy the best tyres for your car, RACV (https://www.racv.com.au/royalauto/transport/cars/car-tyre-buying-guide.html); VSI 8 Guide to modification for motor vehicles, Department of Transport and Planning Victoria (https://transport.vic.gov.au/road-and-active-transport/registration-and-licensing/registration/standard-and-non-standard-vehicle-information/vehicle-standards-information/guide-to-modification-for-motor-vehicles)